meson: simplify intl lookups using Meson's builtin dependency lookup

intl is complicated to look up. Some of that complexity now resides in
Meson, since 0.59.0, via a `dependency('intl')` lookup, so use that
instead.

The Meson lookup doesn't include all the checks here, but likewise this
meson.build doesn't include all the checks in Meson. Particularly, the
following are different:

- Meson accurately detects support built into libc, even if that
  conflicts with an external library version (which should be detected as
  broken and thus not-found, but glib does not do so).

  The problem here is that depending on which libintl.h header is first
  in the search path, the *gettext symbols may be the libc ABI, or they
  may be renamed to libintl_*gettext, then additionally take over the
  *gettext names via a macro, in order to invoke the external library
  version even on systems where there is a libc builtin. This means that
  checking for `cc.has_function()` correctly reports that there is such
  a function in libc, but that unfortunately does not mean it is usable,
  because source code referencing `ngettext` etc. will expect to be
  linked to `libintl_ngettext`.

- glib checks whether the found intl requires pthread, rather than
  simply trusting the result of `cc.find_library()` for the external
  library case.

Do the heavy lifting by using Meson to check for intl, and select the
correct implementation, but do a post-discovery check if the symbol is
linkable both with/without pthread.

The logic is still a bit hairy, and eventually more of the logic could
be moved into Meson. But it's better than before.

Fixes incorrect detection of intl on musl-based systems (which have a
less capable libc intl), when GNU libintl is installed as an external
library.
This commit is contained in:
Eli Schwartz 2022-05-24 15:26:04 -04:00
parent 24ec80cfb4
commit 26435b570f
No known key found for this signature in database
GPG Key ID: CEB167EFB5722BD6

View File

@ -2030,42 +2030,37 @@ libz_dep = dependency('zlib')
# FIXME: glib-gettext.m4 has much more checks to detect broken/uncompatible
# implementations. This could be extended if issues are found in some platforms.
libintl_deps = []
if cc.has_function('ngettext')
have_bind_textdomain_codeset = cc.has_function('bind_textdomain_codeset')
else
# First just find the bare library.
libintl = cc.find_library('intl', required : false)
# The bare library probably won't link without help if it's static.
if libintl.found() and not cc.has_function('ngettext', dependencies : libintl)
libintl_iconv = cc.find_library('iconv', required : false)
# libintl supports different threading APIs, which may not
# require additional flags, but it defaults to using pthreads if
# found. Meson's "threads" dependency does not allow you to
# prefer pthreads. We may not be using pthreads for glib itself
# either so just link the library to satisfy libintl rather than
# also defining the macros with the -pthread flag.
libintl_pthread = cc.find_library('pthread', required : false)
# Try linking with just libiconv.
if libintl_iconv.found() and cc.has_function('ngettext', dependencies : [libintl, libintl_iconv])
libintl_deps += [libintl_iconv]
# Then also try linking with pthreads.
elif libintl_iconv.found() and libintl_pthread.found() and cc.has_function('ngettext', dependencies : [libintl, libintl_iconv, libintl_pthread])
libintl_deps += [libintl_iconv, libintl_pthread]
else
libintl = disabler()
endif
endif
if not libintl.found()
libintl = subproject('proxy-libintl').get_variable('intl_dep')
libintl_deps = [libintl] + libintl_deps
have_bind_textdomain_codeset = true # proxy-libintl supports it
libintl = dependency('intl', required: false)
if libintl.found()
# libintl supports different threading APIs, which may not
# require additional flags, but it defaults to using pthreads if
# found. Meson's "threads" dependency does not allow you to
# prefer pthreads. We may not be using pthreads for glib itself
# either so just link the library to satisfy libintl rather than
# also defining the macros with the -pthread flag.
#
# Meson's builtin dependency lookup as of 0.60.0 doesn't check for
# pthread, so we do this manually here.
if cc.has_function('ngettext', dependencies : libintl)
libintl_deps += [libintl]
else
libintl_deps = [libintl] + libintl_deps
have_bind_textdomain_codeset = cc.has_function('bind_textdomain_codeset',
dependencies : libintl_deps)
libintl_pthread = cc.find_library('pthread', required : false)
if libintl_pthread.found() and cc.has_function('ngettext', dependencies : [libintl, libintl_pthread])
libintl_deps += [libintl, libintl_pthread]
else
libintl = disabler()
endif
endif
endif
if libintl.found()
have_bind_textdomain_codeset = cc.has_function('bind_textdomain_codeset', dependencies: libintl_deps)
else
libintl = subproject('proxy-libintl').get_variable('intl_dep')
libintl_deps = [libintl]
have_bind_textdomain_codeset = true # proxy-libintl supports it
endif
glib_conf.set('HAVE_BIND_TEXTDOMAIN_CODESET', have_bind_textdomain_codeset)
# We require gettext to always be present